Senator Reid makes the Doctors Pay for Medicare under Senate Bill 3590

The politicians are claiming that Senator Reid's bill will save the country money according to the latest CBO report. Physicians were scheduled to have a 21% pay cut caring for Medicare patients as of January 1, 2010. However, under Section 3101, this bill provides for .5% increase for physicians in 2010 but assumes no further increases or change to the Medicare Sustainable Growth Rate formula which is used to compute physician payment rates. It is known to be a flawed formula requiring an act of Congress to "fix" each year. Politicians have always provided some nominal increase in physician payments, even if it has not kept pace with inflation. According to the Alliance of Specialty Medicine, "If the SGR formula is not fixed, physicians will receive negative updates of approximately five percent each year from 2006 until 2013 and rates will not return to their 2002 level until well after 2013. In other words, physicians will receive less reimbursement in 2013 than they did in 2002 for the exact same procedure, regardless of inflation and increases in practice costs." This unrealistically assumes doctors will bear the cost burden for the Medicare population. More likely physicians will have to stop Medicare participation (stop caring for Medicare patients) under these conditions. It seems disingenuous to claim "savings," when not all the costs have been realistically accounted for in this bill. This bill will surely go over the CBO estimates if real world historical political behavior of annual "fixes" are assumed as opposed to the static assumptions of the CBO.